Vistopia
The Origins of Totalitarianism: How Total Domination Works and What It Leaves Behind | Citizenship Course, Season 9
Yang Zhao

The Politicization of the Bourgeoisie and the Expansion of Military Power

Hello, I’m Yang Zhao.
Europe was remarkably peaceful in the second half of the nineteenth century. It might seem that without European wars armies should have become unimportant, but that would be profoundly mistaken.
Arendt moves steadily toward her central concern, the origins of totalitarianism. The politicized bourgeoisie used its immense wealth to control governments and their values. Alongside this expansion of bourgeois political power, soldiers and military institutions continually expanded their own influence.
How did they do so?
European powers divided the Middle East, Arabian Peninsula, and Africa into spheres of influence. Their agreements remained merely lines on maps unless enforced in reality, which required sending armies.
These forces were not primarily needed for conquest. Industrialization, especially modern weapons and military organization, had created an overwhelming disparity that left local societies unable to resist imperial armies.
In ancient and civilized China, the familiar image of the Eight-Nation Alliance’s 1900 invasion shows Walderseeleading allied troops into Beijing. The photograph encourages us to imagine eight countries joining forces to bully China.
In fact, the opening campaign relied mainly on small foreign garrisons already stationed in China. Together they badly defeated the Boxers and Qing forces transferred from Shaanxi; reinforcements arriving from Europe and elsewhere in Asia then entered Beijing. The original garrisons alone exerted immense military pressure, and Beijing had already fallen two months before Waldersee arrived as commander.
The central purpose was therefore not occupation but defense: displaying one’s forces deterred rivals from taking a claimed territory. Armies had to be maintained, expanded, and deployed across the world to garrison, control, and protect possessions against other imperial powers.
Episode editor: dy
2026.09.10
Audio in Chinese

Related programs

Featured comments

4 comments
  • 🍊0
    2026-09-10 19:37:33

    《罪责》:“有罪的无责;有责的无罪……🪞🐖……? 人生无常战战兢兢如履薄冰……

  • 🍊0
    2026-09-10 17:24:04

    《错误的行为》 沉没成本? 人是理性的吗? 行动者不思考? 语言游戏?俄乌……美伊军事所谓“冲突? 天地不仁 以万物为刍狗:承认错误给“谁”看? ……. 芒格老先生的智慧“谎言只能通过谎言加倍来继续……🪞🐖……?

  • t
    truezx
    2026-09-10 13:44:10

    工业化、生产大幅提升,只不过以后,这样的经济成长就停滞了。于是“ 资本过剩”就在**延迟发生了。资本过剩就必须找出路。而资本要找出路,最好是由军队把资本带到有保障安全的地方。 刚开始他们针对**,接下来就看到了**。于是我们看,**走上军国主义的道路。

  • N3
    2026-09-10 12:52:23

    沙发