Vistopia
Classics of Our Century: A Film History of the Twenty-First Century in the Making
Film Debate

Listening Guide

1. 00:21How Letters from Iwo Jima unfolds through officers and ordinary soldiers.
2. 03:01Saigo and Shimizu: two ordinary soldiers who want to live.
3. 07:11Shimizu surrenders but is shot by Americans, overturning the binary of civilization and barbarism.
4. 11:31How Eastwood anticipates American viewers' psychology, then breaks fixed ideas of good and evil.
5. 13:00How can we distinguish a victor displaying tolerance from genuine humanism?
6. 15:43From City of Life and Death to Passenger: does using the perpetrator's perspective usurp another's voice?
7. 16:40One photograph and hundreds of letters represent two forms of war memory.
8. 18:11Writing letters resists death and recovers identities beyond “soldier.”
9. 20:33Kuribayashi sees that the war is meaningless; why does he remain an efficient executor of the system?
10. 26:12He opposes futile suicidal charges yet still believes soldiers should die for the emperor.
11. 28:11War does not distribute fate according to morality or desire.
12. 28:53How the two films dismantle both American and Japanese national myths.
13. 32:23How Japanese audiences interpret Letters from Iwo Jima through four forms of nationalism.

Memorable Lines

1. Wu: The film presents different kinds of soldiers under wartime conditions. If everyone were uniformly good or bad, it would be propaganda.
Ma: Complexity rather than one position. This plot expresses Eastwood's attitude toward so-called heroism:In his worldview, war has no natural moral high ground.An army as a whole may be just or unjust, but individual soldiers do not necessarily follow. Wearing an American uniform does not automatically make someone good, just as wearing a Japanese uniform does not automatically make someone a beast.
Episode editor: 林深
2026.09.25
Audio in Chinese

Related programs