Vistopia
Justice and Reality: Think Like a Lawyer
Zhan Qingyun
Hello, I’m Zhan Qingyun.
We spent considerable time untangling jurisdiction in the South China Sea arbitration, trying to assess neutrally the opposing Chinese and Philippine positions and the tribunal’s explanation—even vigorous defense—of its own jurisdiction.
You may still wonder: if jurisdiction is so important, can a court remain neutral when it alone decides the limits of its own authority?

International Jurisdiction: Institutions Defining Their Own Power

A domestic trial court also decides its jurisdiction, but at least a higher court can review that determination. A dissatisfied party may appeal.
Many international tribunals, by contrast, render final decisions. They are both first and last instance—one-shot courts.
No higher body reviews them, and arbitral awards are commonly final. If jurisdiction cannot be challenged, each tribunal effectively draws the boundary of its own power.
Can anyone with unlimited authority to define their own authority constrain themselves objectively and carefully under law?
Even if we assume no improper motive and trust that judges honor their oaths and legal ideals,
how can such a decision convince the affected parties and states?
The arrangement can endanger the credibility and legitimacy of the proceeding itself.
The South China Sea arbitration is an example. It influenced perceptions not merely of that tribunal, but of the rule of law and international law generally.
Many contemporary scholars still deny that international law is truly law. It lacks robust enforcement institutions and is often seen as an instrument through which great powers govern the world.

Overlaps and Gaps in International Jurisdiction

Its jurisdictional disorder is another problem. Courts created under separate treaties and other international bodies define their own spheres, producing overlap and confusion without an authoritative institution or rule to resolve them.
One result appears to be endless expansion: multiple institutions claim authority over the same matters.
But the same disorder produces the opposite problem. Each court’s jurisdiction is a set; the sets overlap, but leave gaps outside them. Some matters no one wants to address, while others everyone wants to address but no one lawfully can.

Petty Thieves Are Punished; Great Usurpers Become Lords

Episode editor: 丫丫、Q
2019.08.20
Audio in Chinese

Related programs

Featured comments

18 comments
  • 海绵貔貅
    2019-08-20 11:56:42

    谈到国际法,真是隔着屏幕都能感受到阿詹的无奈😂还有本期开场音乐好棒!

  • 小隐于朝
    2021-11-21 17:40:54

    我们需要这样客观冷静的声音,现在尤是

  • 熊猫
    2019-12-17 15:41:01

    窃钩者诛 窃国者诸侯,以前觉得是不是把事情做到极致,看上去坏的事也会好,今天又有了法律层面上新的理解,阿詹真的给我“心灵震颤”🤓

  • m
    mirror
    2019-08-21 06:23:25

    这期也特别好,最近两期好扎实!非常感谢阿詹!

  • 130****6267
    2024-11-11 12:31:21

    胜利都是由胜者书写的……

  • 蝉
    蝉青云
    2021-12-16 23:14:12

    只有听到阿詹的声音,我才感觉自己又一次安静了下来

  • yanzi
    2021-11-10 22:30:03

    天皇是麦克阿瑟放过的,不熟因为天皇自己躲过。

  • 小陈越来越好
    2025-10-26 19:28:12

    精彩!!

  • 吹风机
    2020-02-15 14:45:26

    很喜欢阿詹讲的法律课,阿詹始终告诉我们法律为社会提供确定性的一套规则,也把一些现实问题剥开来了给我们看,让我们有自己的思考空间,真的很喜欢这样的课程。非法学专业的听到觉得受益匪浅。曾经一直觉得自己需要去了解这一块的内容,但是一直没有缘分,现在有了这个机缘巧合,听到阿詹娓娓道来的讲课,觉得太幸运了。阿詹是一个能让我觉得知识很有趣,知识很棒,知识很深奥的好老师!谢谢你呀!(小声bb一句,庄子那句话真棒,画龙点睛,十分有记忆点。(✪▽✪))

  • 看
    看理想了
    2019-08-21 08:03:08

    “一系列的暴力事件”…………

  • 真正的哲学大师
    2024-04-12 10:03:39

    跑了很幸运,干嘛非要惩罚他

  • 吴限
    2024-04-12 08:34:39

    您好 詹青云

  • v
    viperzero
    2021-11-04 11:23:35

    然而时至今日陈同佳依然没有接受应有的审判

  • 熊猫
    2019-12-17 15:24:35

    快要考研了 心里好乱 想听一听阿詹的声音

    熊猫 Reply Xpy :考完啦!谢谢你!

    Xpy :加油💪

  • 1
    185****9527
    2019-11-26 16:33:51

    先打个卡